When Tim Harte returns from the wedding of the president of the United States and his new wife, Tim's friend, Emmy, he is set up on a blind date.

Although he and the woman, Louise, have great fun, they both know there is no sexual chemistry between them.

However, when a run-in with Louise's identical twin, Geena, goes south, Tim finds himself seemingly in trouble with his daughter, her friend, and the twins.

What Tim doesn't know though is that Geena is a mischief-maker, and when Tim attempts to make up to everyone involved, he realizes he's the butt of the joke.

Soon he and Geena are connecting on a deeper level and Tim realizes he may have just met his soulmate …