When murderous cult member "Baby" Jane Lee Rayburn (guest star Nancy Youngblut) is found stabbed to death, Detectives Winters (Skeet Ulrich) and Jaruszalski (Corey Stoll) identify ringleader Denis Watson (guest star Michael Massee) as a possible suspect. Meanwhile, Jane’s former cellmate, Maura Dillon (Bonnie Root), emerges as a suspect after complaints she made against Jane while in prison come to light. However, the case becomes personal when Winters learns that Maura was wrongfully convicted and one of the detectives responsible was his wife Lori (Teri Polo).